Mathematical proofs

Proof by intimidation

Proof by intimidation (or argumentum verbosum) is a jocular phrase used mainly in mathematics to refer to a specific form of hand-waving, whereby one attempts to advance an argument by marking it as obvious or trivial, or by giving an argument loaded with jargon and obscure results. It attempts to intimidate the audience into simply accepting the result without evidence, by appealing to their ignorance and lack of understanding. The phrase is often used when the author is an authority in their field, presenting their proof to people who respect a priori the author's insistence of the validity of the proof, while in other cases, the author might simply claim that their statement is true because it is trivial or because they say so. Usage of this phrase is for the most part in good humour, though it can also appear in serious criticism. A proof by intimidation is often associated with phrases such as: * "Clearly..." * "It is self-evident that..." * "It can be easily shown that..." * "... does not warrant a proof." * "The proof is left as an exercise for the reader." Outside mathematics, "proof by intimidation" is also cited by critics of junk science, to describe cases in which scientific evidence is thrown aside in favour of dubious arguments—such as those presented to the public by articulate advocates who pose as experts in their field. In a memoir, Gian-Carlo Rota claimed that the expression "proof by intimidation" was coined by Mark Kac, to describe a technique used by William Feller in his lectures: He took umbrage when someone interrupted his lecturing by pointing out some glaring mistake. He became red in the face and raised his voice, often to full shouting range. It was reported that on occasion he had asked the objector to leave the classroom. The expression "proof by intimidation" was coined after Feller's lectures (by Mark Kac). During a Feller lecture, the hearer was made to feel privy to some wondrous secret, one that often vanished by magic as he walked out of the classroom at the end of the period. Like many great teachers, Feller was a bit of a con man. — Rota, Gian-Carlo, 1932–1999. (1997). Indiscrete thoughts. Palombi, Fabrizio, 1965–. Boston: Birkhäuser. ISBN 0-8176-3866-0. OCLC 34029702.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link) (Wikipedia).

Video thumbnail

Proof by Induction | Explanation + 3 Examples

In this video, I explain the proof by induction method and show 3 examples of induction proofs! :D Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/braingainzofficial

From playlist Proofs

Video thumbnail

Introduction to Proof by Counter Example

This video provides an introduction to the proof method of proof by counter example. mathispower4u.com

From playlist Symbolic Logic and Proofs (Discrete Math)

Video thumbnail

Introduction to Proof by Induction: Prove 1+3+5+…+(2n-1)=n^2

This video introduces proof by induction and proves 1+3+5+…+(2n-1) equals n^2. mathispower4u.com

From playlist Sequences (Discrete Math)

Video thumbnail

Introduction to Indirect Proof

This video introduces indirect proof and proves one basic algebraic and one basic geometric indirect proof. Complete Video List: http://mathispower4u.yolasite.com/

From playlist Relationships with Triangles

Video thumbnail

Introduction to Proof Methods!

The first video I've made on proof methods! I discuss what a proof is, give some general tips, show how to prove a conditional statement using the direct proof method, and use the direct proof method to do some very beginner friendly proofs! The goals of this video: 1. Help people underst

From playlist Proofs

Video thumbnail

Proof by Contradiction | Explanation + 5 Examples

In this video, I explain the basic idea of the proof by contradiction method. Then I show 5 examples of using proof by contradiction to prove some propositions. Thanks for watching! Comment below with questions, and make sure to keep flexin' those brain muscles! Facebook: https://www.f

From playlist Proofs

Video thumbnail

Math Talk! Heejong Lee, Ph.D. Langlands Program

This is the first official in-person Math Talk! the episode, hopefully with many more to come!

From playlist Math Talk!

Video thumbnail

How to Detect a Liar

I describe How to Detect a Liar. This information was created by combining info from numerous texts and figuring out what every expert agrees on. You'll learn to spot lying in men, women, politicans, etc.

From playlist Negotiation Tutorials

Video thumbnail

Ig Nobel Prize with Leslie Lamport (2013 Turing Award)

2013 Turing Award recipient Leslie Lamport describes his favourite maths t-shirt, his final remaining goal in life, and whether he prefers tabs or spaces… Leslie begins by describing his favourite maths t-shirt, as based on the infamous Donald Knuth video here: https://www.youtube.com/wat

From playlist Interviews

Video thumbnail

Grid Painting Question (2 of 2: Generalising the result)

More resources available at www.misterwootube.com

From playlist The Nature of Proof

Video thumbnail

Direct Proofs Involving Divisibility

In this video, we write direct proofs of four different statements that all involve divisibility of integers. I hope you find it helpful! Timestamps: 0:00 - Intro 0:50 - Definition 3:30 - Proof 1 6:17 - Proof 2 9:41 - Proof 3 12:48 - Proof 4 Thanks for watching! Comment below with quest

From playlist Proofs

Video thumbnail

Age Limit for Studying Math

A common concern people have is "am I too old to study mathematics?". In this video I address this question. Do you have any advice or opinions? If so, please leave a comment below. Geometry Book for Beginners: https://amzn.to/3WXid1K Useful Math Supplies https://amzn.to/3Y5TGcv My Record

From playlist Inspiration and Advice

Video thumbnail

Flatwoods Monster Solved!

Today we return to flatwoods with a shorter video before we finally talk about T.rex. In this video we will discuss new suggestions, Mesopotamian Eye Gods and their possible connection to the Flatwoods Monster, and aliens! (Sorry for the long wait, I have been very busy, the T.rex video wi

From playlist Cryptozoology

Video thumbnail

Stanislav Smirnov, Percolation crossings and complex analysis

2018 Clay Research Conference, CMI at 20

From playlist CMI at 20

Video thumbnail

Introduction to Direct Proofs: If n is even, then n squared is even

This video introduces the mathematical proof method of direct proof provides an example of a direct proof. mathispower4u.com

From playlist Symbolic Logic and Proofs (Discrete Math)

Video thumbnail

A Rhetorical and Legal Analysis of Michael Cohen's Testimony Before Congress (Real Law Review)

⭐️ Get my videos early & ad free (plus my exclusives!) only on Nebula. Save $10 per year! https://legaleagle.link/getnebula ⭐️ Did you hear what Michael Cohen said to Congress? The first 500 Legal Eagles will get 2 months of unlimited learning on Skillshare for FREE: https://legaleagle.l

From playlist Law Review News!

Video thumbnail

Cheaters Can't Cheat: Fairness Protocol Explained [The value in bitcoin, ethereum, open blockchains]

What is really unique and valuable about bitcoin or ethereum? It's more than monetary policy. More than smart contracts. In this video, Andreas explains what he calls, "The Fairness Protocol", using a story from his childhood of his cousins, a bowl of french fries, and the dilemma of how t

From playlist Freedom, Fairness, and Justice: brought to you by bitcoin and open blockchains

Video thumbnail

Proof By Cases | 2 Examples

Two examples of using the proof by cases method. Leave any questions / comments below! Keep flexin' those brain muscles! Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/braingainzofficial Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/braingainzofficial

From playlist Proofs

Video thumbnail

Lecture 10 - Generating Functions

This is Lecture 10 of the CSE547 (Discrete Mathematics) taught by Professor Steven Skiena [http://www.cs.sunysb.edu/~skiena/] at Stony Brook University in 1999. The lecture slides are available at: http://www.cs.sunysb.edu/~algorith/math-video/slides/Lecture%2010.pdf More information may

From playlist CSE547 - Discrete Mathematics - 1999 SBU

Related pages

Triviality (mathematics) | Mathematics | Hand-waving